I've been really into the One Step Pimple Pads for quite a long while now, when I found out there was another version, I was happy to buy it. I perhaps shouldn't have. Whenever I use these, it only makes me miss my other toner pads. The quality of the pads and packaging is excellent, but the effectiveness of the toner is quite lacking. I haven't seen any chance with these at all. It doesn't provide more moisture to my skin, doesn't properly exfoliate, doesn't clear or soothe the skin, doesn't quite work as a first treatment either. I've been thinking of re-soaking these in my COSRX BHA A-Sol, maybe they will finally become effective afterwards.