I had high expectations of this eyeliner, because I saw it had a lot of good reviews. In the beginning it had good color pay-off and it did not smudge. However, after a few weeks the pen really started to dry out. I was confused whether I finished the product or maybe I put it straight up (so the ink did not come out). At the moment, sometimes it does gives of the color well but also very often it does not. Also, during the day I see that the eyeliner smudges a little bit at the outer corners of my eyes when I create a small wing. So to conclude, it’s an ok eyeliner but mine ran out of product quite quickly and does smudge a bit in the corner. So I’m gonna continue my search for the perfect eyeliner. Last point, it comes with a small bottle of eye/lip remover which is really nice. It works well, but I can also remove the eyeliner with my normal makeup remover. But I use this one for traveling, because of its convenient compact size.