I'm very satisfied with this eyeliner. I bought it in the shade #2 Deep brown, which is a really nice, dark brown color that fits my blue eyes. It has a creamy texture and easy to work with. I used it with different brushes already, but the included one also works very nicely. You need to be fast to apply it though, because it dries quickly. It doesn't really smudge during the day and has a decent lasting power. I'd like to purchase it in the cranberry shade too, because it is gorgeous.