I wanted to buy an eyeliner that doesn't contain any alcohol or perfume and also I wanted brown instead of black. This eyeliner has all of this and more, the brush is really nice, you can easily paint thin lines with is, the texture of the paint is really nice it is not too thick, not too thin, very pigmented. The color is really nice, it is a dark rich brown, almost black but not as hars and cold, it fits my fair complexion and light eyes. Doesn't smudge, easy to remove with an oil cleanser.