I think I was a little to harsh on this when I started using this eyebrow pencil. It was much thinner than I expected. I don't think this was the right product for me. I've snapped the lead three times since I've bought it and it already comes with so little product! My heart drops a little at the wasted product. I think I may be too heavy handed for this particular eyebrow pencil. If I could get it to work in my hands, I think it would create the most realistic eyebrow hairs. I got it in the colour #1 Natural Brown, but I can't really get the colour to show up on my brows. It's just not the one for me! Maybe for someone who's looking for a thin lead with a light hand.